Choosing between grid and carousel
The tool offers both, and they solve different problems.
A grid split targets profile visitors. The payoff only exists on your profile page, where the tiles assemble into one image, a banner, a panorama, a big announcement. Feed viewers see the fragments individually and usually scroll past them, so the cost is several weak posts in exchange for one strong profile moment.
A carousel split targets feed viewers. The wide image is cut into swipeable slides inside one post, so the whole experience lives in a single unit: one set of engagement, one caption, no fragments. For panoramas, before-and-afters and step-by-step visuals this is almost always the better trade.
Pick grid when the profile is the destination. Pick carousel when the feed is.
Posting order, the part everyone gets wrong
Instagram fills the grid with the newest post in the top-left corner, and older posts flow right and then down. A split image therefore has to be posted backwards.
For a 3x3 split, post piece 1 first (the bottom-right tile), then 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and finally piece 9, which ends up top-left. Get this wrong and the image assembles mirrored, which is not fixable without deleting and reposting the whole set.
Two practical notes. Post the full set in one sitting; a half-built grid sitting on your profile for three days is worse than no grid. And write real captions for each tile, the tiles are still posts, and a caption saying "part 4 of 9" wastes nine chances to say something.
Keeping the pieces sharp
Splitting multiplies any quality problem in the source image, because each tile gets enlarged to fill a post. Start from the largest, cleanest version you have rather than a screenshot or a re-saved copy.
Aim for a source wide enough that each individual tile still lands around Instagram's display width after the cut, for a three-column split that means starting from roughly three times the width you would use for a single post. If the source is too small, the tiles arrive soft and the assembled grid looks worse than a single well-exported image would have.
Compressing the finished tiles before upload speeds up posting nine files, but do it after the split, not before, compressing first and then enlarging each piece is what produces visible artefacts along the seams.